Two signs in a wood

You’re walking down a country lane in autumn. The leaves are a thousand shades of eye-catching, the air is crisp and leafy. Your spaniel is romping off through the leaf drifts and barking at god-knows-what. Life is grand.

You see a beautiful hand-carved sign up ahead and go to investigate. It has a map, and pictures to identify local birds. Also, in clear and well-constructed prose, it talks of the dangers of letting your dog unleashed in this area. It advises you to be cautious and care for your dog.

You look over at Jelly Bojangles, frolicing like the pup she hasn’t been for years, and decide, “Nah, it’ll be okay.”

Further down the path, the air smells like spices and woodsmoke. A bird you can’t identify sings for a full minute and then leaves the silence even more beautiful.

You spy another sign, this one a crudely-painted bit of metal nailed to a tree. It says, “LEASH YOUR GODDAM DOG I GOT A SHOTGUN”. Unnerved, you clip the leash on Jelly Bojangles and continue your walk.

Which sign is better marketing?

Creative Commons License photo credit:

  • http://www.andyhayes.com Andy Hayes

    I just LOVED LOVED LOVED this. What a story.

    Practically speaking, the 2nd sign is the better marketing tool, because it achieved the desired output: dogs on leash.

    But of course, it begs the question: do you want to be THAT guy? Or do you wanna fix your broken sign. :)

    Merry Christmas Jelly Bojangles.

  • http://www.timothyjohnsoniii.com Timothy Johnson III

    Haha, of course, the 2nd sing is the winner, simply because: It instantly captures your attention, makes you really “get” the message, and TAKE ACTION.

    And, if the sign gets the point across, maybe the sign doesn’t really NEED to be fixed, Andy :-)

  • http://www.anencouragingbird.com BirdyD

    For my peeps – not the second.

    But then, not the first either.

    Third Option, anyone? :-D

  • https://CashAndJoy.com Catherine Caine

    Hello there Andy darling!

    You nailed it exactly. And I’m sure Jelly Bojangles had a marvellous Christmas. :)

  • https://CashAndJoy.com Catherine Caine

    That’s always a personal judgement call. If you’re willing to be That Guy, aka The Scary Shotgun Dude, then by all means use the second sign. A lot of people aren’t comfortable with it, of course.

  • https://CashAndJoy.com Catherine Caine

    Make your own!

  • Stephanie Stroter

    In this instance, I would chose to be THAT guy because I probably wouldn’t care, necessarily, about being nice, but rather, my focus would be you reigning in your mutt!!

  • https://CashAndJoy.com Catherine Caine

    I think you’ve made the right choice, Stephanie!

    But lots of people are too afraid of being THAT guy…

  • Stephanie Stroter

    Being THAT guy has its advantages….LOL!